Not sure where to have dinner tonight? Picture yourself and your loved one enjoying dinner on Shelter Island at one of the most beautiful coastal spots. Watch the sun paint the sky orange and pink at Rams Head Inn as you dig into a delicious sunset dinner. Our restaurant is one of the best dinner ideas for two, painting a picture of relaxation from the bustle of New York.
Dinner Tonight With Shelter Island’s Charm
On Shelter Island in New York, time moves more slowly, and our charming coastal spot keeps its quiet beauty all year long. Part of the appeal is the peaceful views you can expect when sharing a dinner on Shelter Island.
From your table, you can see boats floating in the Coecles Harbor and birds soaring above the waterfront. We welcome everyone: from couples seeking quiet connection to lively groups celebrating under the stars.
The Perfect Sunset Dinner Experience
At The Rams Head Inn on Shelter Island, a sunset dinner is the ideal date night. Our dinner hours are from 5 PM until closing year-round, but you can call us to confirm and make your romantic reservation. Aside from the views, the menu for a Shelter Island dinner is as versatile as the changing colors of the seasons.
With freshly sourced and local seasonal ingredients, you can expect a unique selection of exquisite food with each visit. We take pride in our farm-to-table, sea-to-table, and garden-to-table philosophy. Our menu reflects the very best of what’s grown, raised, and harvested nearby.
Whether you’re basking in the lingering heat from a beautiful summer’s day and crunching on a salad or staying cozy by the fire as you watch the cool blue hues settle over the harbor, your dinner experience will be one for the books!
What’s for Dinner at Rams Head
Wondering, “What should I eat for dinner?” You and your special someone can peruse our expertly crafted menu and even ask our waiters for their seasonal suggestions. You can’t go wrong starting with our house buns, sweetened with honey from our on-site, sustainable apiary. Or you can share tasty roasted oysters while watching the stars twinkle after the sun sets.
We’re proud to use fresh produce from our on-site organic garden, including tomatoes, lettuce, and herbs grown just steps from your table. Our bar team even uses our garden’s harvest for seasonal cocktails, creating drinks that truly taste like Shelter Island.
For mains, you can have anything from housemade pappardelle (crafted by Chef Adam using imported semolina flour) to a delicious seasonal salad. New this summer, we’re excited to introduce Wagyu beef, prepared with care and served with ingredients that let its quality shine.
Our daily catch is a local treasure and perfect to satisfy any seafood cravings, featuring oysters, clams, and scallops sourced from surrounding waters. No matter what you choose, your dinner for two will be the perfect addition to your dreamy date night.
Planning Your Visit to Shelter Island
Getting here adds to the adventure! Choose between a train and ferry to Shelter Island combo, arrive by boat, or enjoy a scenic drive. From Penn Station, take the Montauk Line to Bridgehampton or Ronkonkoma Line to Greenport, then connect to Shelter Island by ferry. Boaters can find us at 41°4.774’N 72°17.791’W, with Captain Dave available on Channel 77 for docking assistance.
Besides transport, make sure to check Shelter Island’s weather beforehand. Our dining room is equipped for cozy winters and pleasant summers, but knowing the weather on Shelter Island can help you plan better. You can even come early for a romantic walk or to browse our luxury swag before dinner. Tip: Sunset looks best after a light rain when the air is clear.
Even More Reasons to Dine With Us
Looking to elevate the experience? Our gazebo offers a charming setting for private dinners under the stars, perfect for special occasions or just an extra dose of romance. In warmer weather, we’re also exploring private dockside dinners for a truly unforgettable evening.
If you’re coming by boat, we welcome groups and charters arriving by water. Just let us know in advance, and we’ll be ready to host your evening by the harbor. And don’t feel rushed; many guests linger for hours, enjoying a relaxed evening that stretches into a slow, satisfying night.
The Rams Head Inn: Dinner and a View
The Rams Head Inn on Shelter Island is the ideal location for a dinner for two because our menu is as tantalizing as our breathtaking views. You can savor our Harvest Salad or RHI burger and marvel at the picture-perfect waterfront sights. From the quality of our locally grown ingredients to the natural beauty all around you, every detail is designed to slow you down, open your senses, and invite you to stay awhile.
Whether you’re marking a special day or just want a nice night out, dinner on Shelter Island, NY, will be a memory you and your beau will cherish for years to come.
